Catholic Commentary
The Heavenly Court: God Permits Satan's Test
6Now on the day when God’s sons came to present themselves before Yahweh, Satan also came among them.7Yahweh said to Satan, “Where have you come from?” Then Satan answered Yahweh, and said, “From going back and forth in the earth, and from walking up and down in it.”8Yahweh said to Satan, “Have you considered my servant, Job? For there is no one like him in the earth, a blameless and an upright man, one who fears God, and turns away from evil.”9Then Satan answered Yahweh, and said, “Does Job fear God for nothing?10Haven’t you made a hedge around him, and around his house, and around all that he has, on every side? You have blessed the work of his hands, and his substance is increased in the land.11But stretch out your hand now, and touch all that he has, and he will renounce you to your face.”12Yahweh said to Satan, “Behold, all that he has is in your power. Only on himself don’t stretch out your hand.” So Satan went out from the presence of Yahweh.
Job 1:6–12 describes a heavenly assembly where Satan accuses God of using blessings to purchase Job's faith, claiming Job would renounce God if stripped of possessions. Yahweh permits Satan to test Job by destroying his wealth but forbids harming Job himself, establishing that true piety exists independent of material blessing and that evil operates only within divine constraint.
Satan challenges God on the deepest question of faith: Does Job love God for nothing—or only because blessing makes it easy?
Commentary
Job 1:6 — The Heavenly Assembly ("sons of God"): The "sons of God" (Hebrew: bene ha-elohim) denote members of the divine council, a cosmological image drawn from ancient Near Eastern tradition but radically reinterpreted in Hebrew monotheism. These are not rival deities but angelic beings who serve Yahweh as a royal court attends a king (cf. 1 Kgs 22:19; Ps 82:1). The phrase "present themselves before Yahweh" uses the Hebrew yityyaṣṣəbû, a term of formal attendance — they are subordinates rendering account. That Satan "came among them" is already theologically loaded: he is not apart from God's sovereign domain but within it, subject to divine summons and authority.
Job 1:7 — God's Question: Yahweh's question "Where have you come from?" is not a request for information but a formal demand for an accounting of activity — echoing God's question to Cain (Gen 4:9) and to Adam (Gen 3:9). Satan's answer, "from going to and fro on the earth, and walking up and down on it," reveals his character: restless, prowling, surveying — a predator seeking prey. The Septuagint reinforces this with perierchomai, "going around," which Peter will echo chillingly in 1 Pet 5:8.
Job 1:8 — God Introduces Job: In a stunning reversal of expectation, it is God, not Job, who initiates the confrontation. Yahweh commends Job using four cumulative descriptors: tam (blameless, wholeness of character), yashar (upright, morally straight), yere Elohim (fears God), and sar mera (turns from evil). These are not abstract virtues but a full moral portrait. The phrase "there is no one like him in the earth" is royal language — the same language used of Solomon's unique wisdom (1 Kgs 3:12). Job is, in a sense, a king of righteousness.
Verses 9–11 — Satan's Accusation: Satan's counterargument is razor-sharp and constitutes the book's central theological question: "Does Job fear God for nothing?" (ḥinnam — gratis, for free). Satan proposes what we might call the "prosperity-piety equation": that genuine faith is impossible, and that what looks like devotion is merely rational self-interest. He accuses not only Job but implicitly God — suggesting that God can only "buy" worship through blessing. The image of the hedge (śak) is one of divine protection, almost womb-like in its completeness (around him, his house, all that he has). Satan's demand is calculated: "stretch out your hand" — he attributes to God the very action that will befall Job, acknowledging that nothing happens outside divine permission.
Job 1:12 — The Divine Permission: Yahweh's response is the theological hinge of the entire prologue. God permits but does not cause the evil. The boundary is precise and non-negotiable: everything external to Job may be touched; Job's person may not. This limitation reveals that even Satan operates under divine constraint — he is not an autonomous force of evil but a creature under authority. The word "power" (Hebrew yad, literally "hand") ironically mirrors Satan's request: God grants Satan a "hand" but forbids him from using his own. This sovereignty-within-permission is one of Scripture's earliest and clearest statements of how divine providence governs evil without authoring it.
Catholic Commentary
Catholic tradition offers singular depth here on three levels.
On Satan: The Catechism teaches that "Satan or the devil and the other demons are fallen angels who have freely refused to serve God and his plan" (CCC §391), and that "the power of Satan is, nonetheless, not infinite. He is only a creature, powerful from the fact that he is pure spirit, but still a creature. He cannot prevent the building up of God's reign" (CCC §395). Job 1:6–12 is a narrative icon of precisely this teaching: Satan is present in the divine court, not as an equal, but as a creature subject to divine governance.
On the Problem of Evil: St. Gregory the Great's monumental Moralia in Job (6th century) — the most extensive patristic commentary on the book — interprets the heavenly scene as an allegory of the spiritual life: the "hedge" is the divine grace that ordinarily protects the soul; its removal is not abandonment but a deeper invitation to heroic virtue. Gregory sees Job as a figura Christi — a type of Christ who is handed over, stripped, and yet vindicates God's name.
On Suffering and Providence: The Second Vatican Council's Gaudium et Spes §22 teaches that Christ "fully reveals man to man himself" including in suffering. Job's trial anticipates the Paschal Mystery: innocent suffering that is bounded, permitted, and ultimately redemptive. The CCC notes that "God permits evil in order to draw forth some greater good" (§311–312), citing Romans 8:28 — a principle Job's prologue dramatizes in its starkest form.
On Disinterested Love: The question "Does Job fear God for nothing?" is answered definitively only at the Cross, where Christ loves the Father with no earthly benefit — indeed, at ultimate cost. Sts. Thomas Aquinas and John of the Cross both cite the Joban dynamic when discussing amor purus, the pure love of God that seeks God for God's own sake, not for consolations or rewards.
For Today
Satan's accusation against Job is remarkably contemporary: that religious practice is ultimately transactional, that people believe because it "works" for them — because faith delivers health, prosperity, or psychological comfort. When suffering strips away those benefits, faith collapses. This is precisely the crisis many Catholics face: a faith built primarily on answered prayers, family stability, or felt consolation that shatters when tragedy strikes.
Job 1:6–12 invites Catholics to a searching self-examination: Why do I follow Christ? St. Ignatius of Loyola's First Principle and Foundation is a direct answer to Satan's challenge — "Man is created to praise, reverence, and serve God our Lord, and by this means to save his soul" — full stop. Not contingent on comfort.
Practically, this passage counsels three things: first, to cultivate faith during times of blessing so it has roots for times of trial; second, to recognize that suffering allowed by God is not outside His care but within His bounded, purposeful sovereignty; third, to find consolation in the fact that our faithfulness under trial — like Job's — is itself a glorification of God. The hedge may be lifted; the love need not be.
Cross-References