Catholic Commentary
David Withdraws to the Strongholds of En Gedi
29David went up from there and lived in the strongholds of En Gedi.
1 Samuel 23:29 describes David's movement from the wilderness of Maon to the fortified caves of En Gedi, a dramatic landscape of cliffs and springs overlooking the Dead Sea, where he establishes refuge during his flight from Saul. The passage marks a spiritual transition, with David's ascent into this harsh wilderness reflecting God's shaping of his character through adversity and isolation.
David's flight into the desert stronghold of En Gedi is not defeat but the hidden arena where God prepares a king — proving that sometimes faithfulness looks like waiting, not conquering.
Catholic tradition reads David's wilderness sojourn through several intersecting lenses that uniquely deepen the meaning of this verse.
David as Type of Christ: The Church Fathers, particularly St. Justin Martyr (Dialogue with Trypho, 103) and St. Ambrose (On the Duties of the Clergy), consistently present the persecuted David as a type (typos) of the suffering Christ. As David was unjustly hunted by the king he faithfully served, so Christ was delivered to death by the leaders of the very people he came to save. En Gedi's caves thus anticipate both the Garden of Gethsemane and the tomb — places of hiddenness where God's redemptive purposes are mysteriously at work.
The Desert as Theological Space: The Catechism of the Catholic Church (§2595) recognizes that the Psalms "express and glorify the wonderful deeds of God in the history of his people" — and many of those Psalms are explicitly set in David's desert period (e.g., Psalm 57, 142). The desert (midbar) in Hebrew thought is not merely a geographical reality but a theological category: the place of encounter with God, of purification, and of covenant renewal. Pope Benedict XVI, in Jesus of Nazareth (Vol. 1), draws this line explicitly when he reflects on Jesus' forty days in the desert as a recapitulation of Israel's and David's wilderness experience.
Providence and Hiddenness: The Catechism teaches that "God's almighty providence is at work in all events" (§303). David's flight to En Gedi is not the abandonment of God's promise but its hidden unfolding. This is precisely what St. John of the Cross calls la noche oscura — the dark night in which God works most profoundly precisely when human activity is suspended and the soul waits in apparent desolation. David in the stronghold is being prepared, not punished.
En Gedi speaks directly to the Catholic who feels pursued — by failure, illness, professional hostility, or the spiritual aridity that comes when the consolations of faith seem to have dried up. The temptation in such seasons is to read God's silence as abandonment, or tactical retreat as defeat. David's withdrawal to the strongholds offers a counter-narrative: sometimes faithfulness looks like hiding, waiting, and surviving rather than conquering.
Concretely, this verse invites Catholics to identify their own "En Gedi" — a specific practice of intentional withdrawal that makes space for God: a regular hour of silent prayer, an annual retreat, fasting from digital noise, or simply choosing not to defend oneself when attacked, trusting that God will intervene as he did at Sela Hammah-leqoth. The desert fathers (especially as recovered by Pope St. John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI) remind us that the soul needs its stronghold — a place of stripping away, where the living water of grace springs up precisely where the world expects only rock and dust. Where is your En Gedi?
Commentary
1 Samuel 23:29 — "David went up from there and lived in the strongholds of En Gedi."
The verse is a hinge moment, brief but dense with geographical, narrative, and theological significance. To appreciate its full weight, we must understand where David is coming from and what En Gedi represents.
"Went up from there" — "There" refers to the wilderness of Maon (23:24–28), where David and his men had just experienced a near-miraculous deliverance. Saul had encircled David on one side of a mountain while David's band clung to the other — a noose drawing tight — when a messenger arrived reporting a Philistine raid, forcing Saul to break off the pursuit. The place was thereafter called Sela Hammah-leqoth, "the rock of division" or "the rock of slipping away" (23:28), a name commemorating God's hidden intervention. It is from this precipice of danger that David now "goes up."
The verb alah (went up) is theologically charged throughout the Hebrew Bible. It frequently signals movement toward the sacred — going up to Jerusalem, going up to the Temple, going up to God. Here, David's ascent into the harsh highlands west of the Dead Sea carries this resonance: he climbs not merely for military security but into a kind of sacred wilderness, the liminal space where God shapes his servants.
"The strongholds of En Gedi" — En Gedi (Ein Gedi, "spring of the young goat") is one of the most dramatic landscapes in the ancient Near East. Located approximately 400 meters above the Dead Sea shore on sheer limestone cliffs riddled with caves, it boasts a freshwater spring that produces a shocking burst of life — lush vegetation, waterfalls, and rich wildlife — in the middle of an otherwise desolate Judean desert. The "strongholds" (metsadot) are the natural cave fortresses and rocky redoubts carved into these cliffs, offering near-impregnable refuge. Archaeology confirms the region's ancient habitation; its caves functioned as hideouts precisely because of their inaccessibility.
That David lives (yeshev) in these strongholds — the same verb used for settled, permanent dwelling — signals more than tactical retreat. He is making the desert his home. This is the wilderness of formation, the same kind of terrain where Moses fled from Pharaoh, where Elijah fled from Jezebel, and where Israel was shaped by God for forty years. The desert strips away pretension and comfort and forces total reliance on God.
Typological and Spiritual Senses: In the allegorical sense, David's hiding in the rock-caves of En Gedi anticipates the soul's refuge in Christ, the true "rock" (1 Cor 10:4). The barrenness that surrounds En Gedi's miraculous spring images the soul that finds in Christ a source of living water amid the aridity of the world. Augustine, commenting on the Psalms attributed to David's wilderness period, consistently reads the persecuted David as a figura of Christ harried by those who sought to destroy him — and equally of the Church, pursued by the world yet kept safe in God's providence. In the moral sense, David's retreat models the spiritual discipline of withdrawal: the willingness to abandon status, comfort, and the field of action when God calls one to hiddenness and waiting.