Catholic Commentary
Seek Good, Not Evil: The Conditional Hope for the Remnant
14Seek good, and not evil, that you may live; and so Yahweh, the God of Armies, will be with you, as you say.15Hate evil, love good, and establish justice in the courts. It may be that Yahweh, the God of Armies, will be gracious to the remnant of Joseph.”
Amos 5:14–15 calls Israel to seek good and hate evil rather than performing empty religious rituals, promising divine favor only if they establish justice through reformed institutions. The passage uses conditional language to hold open the possibility of God's grace for a remnant, contingent upon genuine moral transformation in both personal desire and public practice.
Amos strips away religious performance and demands that your desires be reordered—you must hate evil and love good from the inside out, not just avoid it from the outside in.
The "remnant of Joseph" (representing the northern kingdom, Ephraim/Manasseh) signals that Amos already envisions most of Israel as lost. He is not addressing the nation at its height but a surviving fragment. The doctrine of the remnant — a purified, faithful core preserved through judgment — runs as a golden thread from Amos through Isaiah, Micah, Zephaniah, and into the New Testament theology of election.
Catholic tradition illuminates these verses with particular depth at three levels.
Moral and Virtuous Life: The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that the moral life involves not only external acts but the ordering of the passions and affections: "In themselves passions are neither good nor evil… They are morally qualified by the extent to which they are governed by reason and will" (CCC 1767). Amos's command to "hate evil and love good" anticipates exactly this interior dimension. St. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle and Scripture, argues that true virtue requires that one feel the right thing, not merely do it (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 59, a. 5). A person who refrains from injustice while inwardly loving it is not yet virtuous. Amos demands the complete person — will, affection, and action — turned toward the good.
Social Justice and Catholic Social Teaching: The command to "establish justice in the gate" resonates profoundly with the Church's social doctrine. Rerum Novarum (Leo XIII, 1891) inaugurated a tradition of insisting that justice must be embedded in social structures, not left to private charity alone. Gaudium et Spes (Vatican II, §29) echoes Amos in condemning any social arrangement that degrades human dignity. The Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church explicitly roots Catholic social teaching in the prophetic tradition, noting that the prophets "reminded Israel that the covenant with God implied… just social relations" (§24).
The Remnant and the Church: The Fathers saw in the "remnant of Joseph" a type of the Church — a purified community preserved through judgment and called to holiness. St. Jerome commented on similar remnant texts as pointing to those who, through repentance, are grafted into the New Covenant. Paul explicitly deploys the remnant theology of the prophets in Romans 9–11 to explain the mystery of Israel and the Church. Vatican II's Lumen Gentium (§9) draws on this imagery in describing the Church as the new People of God, formed not by ethnic identity but by faithful response to the covenant.
Contemporary Catholics face a temptation structurally identical to Amos's Israel: the substitution of religious activity for moral conversion. Mass attendance, rosaries, and parish involvement are genuine goods — but Amos warns that they can become a kind of spiritual alibi, a way of saying "the LORD is with us" while leaving the deeper reordering of our desires untouched. The specific command to "establish justice in the gate" challenges Catholics in public life — lawyers, judges, legislators, employers, landlords — to ask not only "am I personally pious?" but "are the institutions I shape, vote for, or benefit from marked by justice for the vulnerable?" The ʾûlay — the "perhaps" of verse 15 — is also a pastoral gift. It refuses both presumption and despair. For Catholics weighed down by personal or communal sin, it holds open a door: conversion is possible, grace remains sovereign, and even a remnant can become the seed of renewal.
Commentary
Amos 5:14 — "Seek good, and not evil, that you may live; and so the LORD, the God of hosts, will be with you, as you have said."
The imperative diršû ("seek") in Hebrew is the same verb used elsewhere for seeking God himself (Amos 5:4, 6). This is no accident. Amos equates the genuine seeking of God with the seeking of moral good — a direct rebuke to the cultic establishment at Bethel and Gilgal, where Israel performed elaborate liturgies while oppressing the poor (5:5, 10–12). The prophet collapses the distance between worship and ethics: you cannot seek YHWH at the sanctuary while abandoning goodness in the marketplace.
The phrase "that you may live" (wichyû) echoes the covenantal life-or-death framework of Deuteronomy. Life here is not merely biological survival but the shalom-existence of a people dwelling rightly with God and neighbor. Its opposite — death — is the covenant curse already looming over Israel through Assyrian aggression. The sardonic sting in "as you have said" is crucial: Israel had been assuring itself of divine favor ("The LORD is with us"), invoking a covenant status they had long since emptied of its moral content. Amos throws their own pious words back at them as a conditional — if you seek good, then what you claim will actually be true.
Amos 5:15 — "Hate evil, and love good, and establish justice in the gate; it may be that the LORD, the God of hosts, will be gracious to the remnant of Joseph."
Verse 15 sharpens the command from the cognitive-volitional ("seek") to the affective ("hate… love"). This is not merely a call to right action but to a transformation of desire itself — the interior reordering that Catholic moral theology identifies with virtue. To hate evil (śinʾû rāʿ) and love good (ʾahăbû ṭôb) is to have one's appetitive faculties properly ordered, what Aquinas would call the rectification of the passions under right reason and grace.
"Establish justice in the gate" (wehaṣṣîgû baššaʿar mišpāṭ) is pointedly institutional. The "gate" was the ancient Near Eastern courthouse, where elders adjudicated disputes, contracts were witnessed, and the vulnerable sought redress. Amos is not calling for private piety alone but for the reform of public institutions. Justice must be made structurally present — established, not merely wished for.
The conclusion — "it may be that the LORD… will be gracious" — is one of Scripture's most honest conditional clauses. The Hebrew ("perhaps," "maybe") does not guarantee restoration. It holds open a door without forcing it. God's grace remains sovereign and free; human repentance does not mechanically compel divine favor. This is a theology of hope that is neither presumptuous nor despairing — exactly the narrow path Catholic tradition calls , hope as a theological virtue.