Catholic Commentary
Third Mockery: Idols Carried, Tarnished, and Served by Corrupt Priests
24Notwithstanding the gold with which they are covered to make them beautiful, unless someone wipes off the tarnish, they won’t shine; for they didn’t even feel it when they were molten.25Things in which there is no breath are bought at any cost.26Having no feet, they are carried upon shoulders. By this, they declare to men that they are worth nothing.27Those who serve them are also ashamed, for if they fall to the ground at any time, they can’t rise up again by themselves. If they are bowed down, they can’t make themselves straight; but the offerings are set before them, as if they were dead men.28And the things that are sacrificed to them, their priests sell and spend. In like manner, their wives also lay up part of it in salt; but to the poor and to the impotent they give none of it.29The menstruous woman and the woman in childbed touch their sacrifices, knowing therefore by these things that they are no gods. Don’t fear them.
The idol cannot even perceive the fire of its own creation — so how could it possibly hear your prayers?
In this third wave of satirical polemic, the Letter of Jeremiah (Baruch 6) exposes the radical impotence of idols through a cascade of concrete, humiliating details: they tarnish, they must be carried, they fall and cannot rise, and their priests exploit their offerings for personal gain while excluding the poor. The passage concludes with the most ritually charged insult of all — that women in states of Levitical impurity handle these so-called gods without consequence — and drives home its refrain: "Don't fear them." The cumulative effect dismantles every claim of divinity by demonstrating that an idol has no agency, no life, and no moral authority.
Verse 24 — Gold That Cannot Shine Without Human Help The verse opens with a concession that ironically backfires on idolatry's defenders: yes, the idols are covered in gold — the most luminous and incorruptible of metals, long associated with divine glory. Yet the gold itself tarnishes unless a human being wipes it clean. The idol's own supposed splendor is contingent on constant human maintenance. More devastating still is the parenthetical remark "for they didn't even feel it when they were molten" — the idol was insensible during its own creation. A god who cannot perceive the fire of its own making cannot perceive the prayers of its worshipers. The Greek verb for "feel" (ᾔσθοντο) connotes conscious sensation and awareness; its negation here is a direct assault on any claim to divine consciousness.
Verse 25 — Purchased Divinity "Things in which there is no breath are bought at any cost." The phrase "no breath" (οὐκ ἔστιν πνεῦμα) is theologically loaded. The Hebrew-Jewish tradition consistently identifies the breath of life — the nišmat ḥayyîm of Genesis 2:7 — as the exclusive gift of the living God. An idol purchased in a marketplace is the inverse of that gift: it is inert matter dressed up at great expense. The commercial transaction itself is the indictment. Genuine divinity cannot be bought; it can only be received. The "any cost" highlights not devotion but absurdity — extravagant resources poured into nothingness.
Verse 26 — Carried on Shoulders, Declaring Their Worthlessness This verse is the satirical heart of the cluster. The idol has no feet — it cannot walk, act, or come to the aid of its devotee. It must be borne aloft on human shoulders, like luggage or a corpse. The author does not merely note this as a logistical detail; he declares that this fact itself is a public testimony ("they declare to men that they are worth nothing"). The idol's procession, intended by its worshipers as a display of power, becomes an unwitting confession of impotence. Isaiah 46:1–7 provides the exact parallel: Bel and Nebo are described as burdens on weary beasts — gods that must be "carried" rather than carrying their people.
Verse 27 — The God That Falls and Cannot Rise The pastoral absurdity deepens: if an idol topples, it lies prostrate until a human sets it upright. The verb "bowed down" may also evoke the posture of worship — yet the idol cannot even perform the action ascribed to it by its devotees. The closing image, "as if they were dead men," is the author's own interpretive gloss, and it is precise: the offerings set before idols are exactly like the food offerings placed before a corpse in ancient Near Eastern burial customs. This is not worship; it is a funeral rite directed at something that was never alive.
Catholic tradition reads this passage within a broader theology of idolatry that the Catechism of the Catholic Church addresses directly. The CCC teaches that idolatry "consists in divinizing what is not God" and that it "perverts our innate sense of God" (CCC 2113–2114). Baruch 6 is one of Scripture's most methodical demonstrations of why this perversion is irrational as well as sinful: the idol cannot do what divinity, by definition, must do — act, perceive, sustain life, and demand holiness.
St. John Chrysostom, in his homilies against the pagans, drew precisely on this kind of prophetic polemic, arguing that the poverty of idols is best exposed not by philosophical argument alone but by observing what they fail to do. St. Augustine in City of God (Book VIII) similarly insists that only a being of genuine transcendence and moral goodness deserves worship, a standard idols catastrophically fail.
The Church Fathers also noted the connection between corrupt priesthood and false religion illustrated in verse 28. St. Irenaeus (Adversus Haereses IV.8) observed that a priesthood that serves itself rather than God and the poor has fundamentally replicated pagan cultic dysfunction. This stands in sharp contrast to the Catholic theology of priesthood as sacrificium, a self-giving ordered entirely toward God and neighbor.
Typologically, the idol carried helplessly on shoulders (v. 26) anticipates the contrast drawn in patristic commentary between the false gods borne by men and the true God who in the Incarnation "bears" humanity — the Word who carries his Cross and, through it, carries us. Pope Benedict XVI (Verbum Domini, 42) notes that Scripture's anti-idol polemic is ultimately a Christological preparation: it clears the ground for recognition of the one Logos who alone gives life, breath, and meaning.
Contemporary Catholics live in a culture rich with sophisticated idolatries — not golden statues, but systems of meaning that promise agency, security, and significance while delivering exactly the passivity and corruption Baruch satirizes. Financial markets, algorithms, political movements, and celebrity culture are all, in their distorted forms, examples of what this text describes: things "bought at any cost," carried by human effort, insensible to suffering, maintained by those who profit from them, and unable to rise when they fall.
The pastoral command "Don't fear them" is urgently needed. Much Catholic anxiety — about cultural decline, political instability, economic precarity — has the structure of idol-fear: an attribution of ultimate power to things that are, in the end, contingent and mortal. The Letter of Jeremiah invites not naivety but a disciplined refusal to grant final authority to anything that cannot breathe life, demand holiness, or care for the poor. Practically, Catholics might ask: What am I maintaining at great personal cost that has never once acted on my behalf? What am I carrying that I have mistaken for something that carries me? These verses are an invitation to set down the burden and turn back to the living God.
Verse 28 — Priestly Corruption as Evidence of Idol-Nullity The priests who tend these idols sell the sacrificial meat for personal profit, and their wives preserve portions in salt (a detail that evokes both domestic economy and the ritual use of salt in legitimate Israelite sacrifice, cf. Lev 2:13). The explicit note that "to the poor and to the impotent they give none of it" is doubly damning: it exposes the priests as exploiters, and it implicitly contrasts the living God of Israel, whose Law mandates care for the poor, widow, and stranger. A true priesthood is ordered toward justice; this one is ordered toward self-enrichment.
Verse 29 — Ritual Impurity as the Final Proof In the Levitical system (Lev 15:19–33), a menstruating woman was in a state of ritual impurity that would be transmitted to sacred objects she touched. That such women handle the idols' sacrifices "without consequence" — without any divine reaction — proves definitively that no sacred power inheres in the idol. This is not a misogynistic remark but a precise deployment of Israel's own purity logic as a theological weapon: if the idol were truly divine, contact with ritual impurity would be a crisis demanding atonement. Since nothing happens, the idol is demonstrated to be nothing. The passage ends, as several clusters in this letter do, with the imperative: "Don't fear them" — a direct pastoral command grounded not in abstract argument but in the accumulated evidence of verses 24–29.