Catholic Commentary
Moses and Aaron Mediate God's Response and the Glory Appears
6Moses and Aaron said to all the children of Israel, “At evening, you shall know that Yahweh has brought you out from the land of Egypt.7In the morning, you shall see Yahweh’s glory; because he hears your murmurings against Yahweh. Who are we, that you murmur against us?”8Moses said, “Now Yahweh will give you meat to eat in the evening, and in the morning bread to satisfy you, because Yahweh hears your murmurings which you murmur against him. And who are we? Your murmurings are not against us, but against Yahweh.”9Moses said to Aaron, “Tell all the congregation of the children of Israel, ‘Come close to Yahweh, for he has heard your murmurings.’”10As Aaron spoke to the whole congregation of the children of Israel, they looked toward the wilderness, and behold, Yahweh’s glory appeared in the cloud.11Yahweh spoke to Moses, saying,12“I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel. Speak to them, saying, ‘At evening you shall eat meat, and in the morning you shall be filled with bread. Then you will know that I am Yahweh your God.’”
Exodus 16:6–12 records Moses and Aaron's promise that God will provide meat in the evening and bread in the morning as proof of his identity and continued care for Israel in the wilderness. The passage emphasizes that Israel's murmuring against the leaders is actually rebellion against God, and God responds by appearing in glory and committing himself to sustain the people through visible, sacramental signs of covenant faithfulness.
When you murmur against your priest, your bishop, your life—you are murmuring against God, and he hears you with mercy, not punishment.
Commentary
Exodus 16:6 — "At evening you shall know that Yahweh has brought you out." Moses and Aaron open not with reproach but with a theological re-narration. The verb "know" (yādaʿ) in Hebrew carries experiential weight: this is not mere intellectual information but recognition through lived event. The evening announcement points forward to the quail (cf. v. 13), which will arrive at dusk. The Exodus itself is being re-anchored as the ground of God's continued action — the same God who freed them from Egypt is the one who now feeds them. Israel's amnesia about the Exodus is precisely what their murmuring reveals (v. 3), and Moses reminds them of it before God acts again.
Exodus 16:7 — "In the morning you shall see Yahweh's glory." The pairing of evening/morning is liturgically significant: it maps onto the Hebrew day (evening precedes morning) and foreshadows the Eucharistic rhythms of the Church's daily prayer. The "glory" (kābôd) of Yahweh is not a vague luminosity but the weighty, sovereign presence of God himself — the same cloud-and-fire that led Israel out of Egypt (Ex 13:21). The rhetorical question "Who are we?" is theologically charged: Moses and Aaron explicitly deflect honor away from themselves. They are not the authors of deliverance; they are its instruments. The murmuring is not a social offense against leaders; it is a theological rebellion against God.
Exodus 16:8 — The Double Provision Articulated. Moses elaborates the double gift — meat in the evening, bread in the morning — before it has happened. This forward proclamation itself is a prophetic act, staking the credibility of Moses' office on God's response. The repeated phrase "Yahweh hears your murmurings" is striking: the Hebrew shāmaʿ (to hear/obey) appears three times in verses 7–9 alone, underscoring that Israel's complaint, though faithless, has not gone unregistered by God. The phrase "your murmurings are not against us but against Yahweh" echoes the pattern of 1 Samuel 8:7, where Israel's rejection of Samuel is interpreted as rejection of God himself — mediators and kings are transparent to the One they represent.
Exodus 16:9 — "Come close to Yahweh." Aaron's instruction to "come close" (qirbû) is a cultic term. In Levitical and priestly contexts, drawing near to God implies both an act of worship and an acknowledgment of dependence. The congregation is being summoned not merely to receive a gift but to enter into a posture of covenant relationship. This drawing-near, notably, precedes the theophany — the people are oriented toward God before the glory appears.
Exodus 16:10 — The Glory Appears in the Cloud. The theophany is sudden, almost breathtaking in the narrative: "they looked toward the wilderness, and behold, Yahweh's glory appeared in the cloud." The wilderness (midbār) is the terrain of divine encounter in Israel's tradition — inhospitable, stripped of human self-sufficiency, and therefore the place where God is most visible. The cloud (ʿānān) is the same pillar that had guided them (Ex 13:21–22) and would later fill the Tabernacle (Ex 40:34–35). God's glory appearing in response to faithful priestly action (Aaron's summoning) models the pattern of liturgical theophany: where the Church gathers in prayer and draws near, God manifests his presence.
Verses 11–12 — God Speaks and Interprets His Own Action. God does not merely act; he speaks the meaning of his action. "You will know that I am Yahweh your God" — the ʾănî YHWH formula is the self-revelatory declaration of covenant identity, appearing throughout Leviticus and Ezekiel as the telos of God's saving deeds. The bread and meat are not merely caloric relief; they are pedagogical sacraments — visible signs through which Israel is meant to arrive at knowledge of God. The double provision (meat in evening, bread in morning) is, in the fuller canonical sense, an enacted parable of the Eucharist, where Christ gives himself as both sacrifice and sustaining food.
Typological Sense: Patristic exegetes (Origin, Tertullian, Ambrose) read the manna of vv. 4–5 and this passage's bread promise as a type of the Eucharist. But this cluster specifically highlights the mediatorial and theophanic dimensions: Moses and Aaron as types of Christ the one Mediator and of the ordained priesthood; the glory in the cloud as a type of the Real Presence; and the self-humbling of the ministers ("Who are we?") as a model for priestly identity.
Catholic Commentary
Catholic tradition finds in this passage a rich matrix of teaching on mediation, priesthood, and the Eucharist.
On Mediation and Priesthood: Moses and Aaron together model the two dimensions of priestly ministry: prophetic proclamation (Moses speaks God's word) and liturgical summoning (Aaron draws the people near). The insistence that the complaint is "against Yahweh, not against us" maps directly onto the Catholic theology of holy orders, in which the ordained minister acts in persona Christi — not on his own authority, but as a transparent instrument of Christ. The Catechism teaches that "in the ecclesial service of the ordained minister, it is Christ himself who is present to his Church" (CCC 1548). The humility of Moses and Aaron — "Who are we?" — is the spiritual posture every priest must interiorize.
On the Glory of God and the Eucharist: The Fathers consistently read the bread promised here, and the manna that follows, as a type of the Eucharist. St. Ambrose writes in De Mysteriis (9.50): "That bread is ordinary bread before the words of the sacrament; but after consecration, the bread becomes the body of Christ." The appearance of God's glory in the cloud when the people "draw near" prefigures the mystery of the Real Presence, where Christ's glory is veiled under the appearances of bread and wine. The Fourth Eucharistic Prayer echoes this: God "did not abandon [humanity] to the power of death… but helped all people to seek and find him."
On God's Hearing and Providence: The Catechism teaches that "God hears the prayer of those who invoke him" (CCC 2616). That he hears even murmuring — faithless, ingrate complaint — reveals the gratuitous nature of divine mercy, foundational to Catholic teaching on grace (CCC 1996–1998). God's provision does not wait for perfect faith; it precedes and creates it.
For Today
In an age of pervasive complaint — against institutions, against the Church, against God's apparent silence — this passage offers a precise diagnosis and a remedy. Moses' words name something most of us instinctively avoid: our frustration with visible, human ministers (priests, bishops, parents, leaders) is very often, at its root, a complaint against God for the shape of the life he has given us. The spiritual discipline this passage invites is a reorientation of our grievance: not "why has the Church failed me?" but "Lord, I am murmuring against You — hear me."
More concretely, Aaron's summons — "Come close to Yahweh" — is issued precisely in the midst of the people's faithlessness, before the glory appears. Catholics are invited to make this movement habitually, especially in the Liturgy of the Hours (the Church's morning and evening prayer), which mirrors the manna's rhythm of daily bread. The Eucharist itself is the fullest answer to this summons: in drawing near to Mass, even in spiritual dryness or doubt, we place ourselves where the glory appears. The wilderness is not an obstacle to encountering God; it is the address where he meets us.
Cross-References