Catholic Commentary
Jacob Deceives Isaac and Receives the Blessing (Part 2)
26His father Isaac said to him, “Come near now, and kiss me, my son.”27He came near, and kissed him. He smelled the smell of his clothing, and blessed him, and said, “Behold, the smell of my son is as the smell of a field which Yahweh has blessed.28God give you of the dew of the sky, of the fatness of the earth, and plenty of grain and new wine.29Let peoples serve you, and nations bow down to you. Be lord over your brothers. Let your mother’s sons bow down to you. Cursed be everyone who curses you. Blessed be everyone who blesses you.”
Genesis 27:26–29 describes Isaac's blessing of Jacob, whom he believes to be his firstborn son Esau, based on sensory confirmation through a kiss and the smell of Esau's clothing. The blessing grants agricultural fertility, political sovereignty over peoples, and continuation of the Abrahamic covenant, establishing Jacob as the heir despite the deception underlying the transaction.
Grace is not given to the worthy—Jacob receives the patriarchal blessing that shapes salvation history while wearing his brother's stolen clothes.
Commentary
Genesis 27:26 — "Come near now, and kiss me, my son." Isaac's command is intimate and familial: the kiss in the ancient Near East was not merely affectionate but a formal gesture of covenant and recognition. Isaac, nearly blind, requires physical proximity to complete his identification of the one before him. The word translated "come near" (Hebrew: gashah) is used elsewhere of drawing near to God or to sacred moments (cf. Ex 24:2), and its use here charges this domestic scene with solemnity. Isaac has already been partially deceived by the feel of the goatskins and the taste of food (vv. 21–25); now he seeks the confirmatory intimacy of a kiss. The pathos is deep: a dying father reaches out in tenderness to a son he cannot see, while that son is, in fact, someone else entirely. The reader is caught between admiration for Jacob's audacity and discomfort at the exploitation of parental love.
Genesis 27:27 — "He came near, and kissed him. He smelled the smell of his clothing, and blessed him." The narrative detail that Isaac smells Jacob's clothing — the garments of Esau that Rebekah had dressed Jacob in — is pivotal. The smell of the field on Esau's clothes becomes the final sensory confirmation Isaac needed. His blessing, therefore, flows directly from this act of smelling. There is a haunting irony: what triggers the blessing is a disguise, a falseness, yet the blessing itself will prove utterly true and utterly efficacious. The word "blessed" (barak) here initiates a formal, quasi-legal act. In the ancient world, a patriarchal deathbed blessing was not merely a warm wish; it carried the weight of a will, a covenant declaration, a transference of destiny. Once spoken, it could not be recalled (cf. v. 33, 37).
Genesis 27:28 — "God give you of the dew of the sky…" The blessing itself opens with agricultural fertility: dew (tal) in the semi-arid land of Canaan was essential for crops, representing divine favour and provision (cf. Deut 33:28; Hos 14:5). The phrase "dew of the sky and fatness of the earth" is a merism — sky above and earth below — encompassing total material blessing. Grain and wine (tirosh, new wine) are listed because they were the staple measures of prosperity in agrarian Israelite culture, and they will later become the materials of the Eucharist itself. The grammar is jussive ("may God give"), expressing a solemn wish-prayer, not a divine oracle in the strict prophetic sense — and yet the narrative treats it as binding.
Genesis 27:29 — "Let peoples serve you…" The blessing escalates from agricultural abundance to political sovereignty. The verb 'avad ("serve/be slave to") anticipates the future subjugation of Canaanite and Edomite peoples to Israel. "Your mother's sons bow down to you" points directly to Esau and his descendants (Edom), fulfilled historically when David subdued Edom (2 Sam 8:14). The final couplet — "cursed be those who curse you, blessed be those who bless you" — directly echoes the Abrahamic promise (Gen 12:3), explicitly tethering Jacob's blessing to the original covenant made with Abraham. Jacob is now unambiguously the heir of the Abrahamic covenant; the blessing is not merely personal prosperity but the continuation of salvation history itself.
The Typological/Spiritual Senses: The Church Fathers, notably St. Ambrose (On Jacob and the Happy Life) and St. Augustine (Contra Faustum XXII), read this passage typologically with great confidence. Jacob, the younger son who "supplants" (the meaning of his name, from 'aqav) by wearing the garments of another, prefigures Christ or, more precisely, the Church receiving the blessing originally intended for Israel-according-to-the-flesh (Esau). The goatskins covering Jacob's smooth skin evoke Christ taking on our sinful flesh — "made sin for us" (2 Cor 5:21) — to receive from the Father the blessing of covenant inheritance on humanity's behalf. Origen further notes that the smell of Esau's garments, which moves Isaac to bless, is a figure of Christ's good works "clothing" the sinner who presents himself to the Father.
Catholic Commentary
Catholic tradition reads this passage at multiple levels simultaneously, in accord with the fourfold sense of Scripture affirmed by the Catechism (CCC §115–118).
At the literal-historical level, the Catholic tradition does not sanitise Jacob's deception. St. Augustine, wrestling honestly with the text in Contra Faustum, insists that Jacob did not lie but acted in a "mystery" (mysterium), his deception being a figura rather than a moral model. This is not a blanket excuse for dishonesty but a recognition that Providence can work through flawed human choices without thereby endorsing them — a principle the Catechism upholds when it acknowledges that God "permits evil in order to draw forth some greater good" (CCC §412).
At the typological level, St. Ambrose's De Iacob et Vita Beata offers the richest patristic reading: Jacob dressed in Esau's garments represents the Church clothed in the merits of Christ, approaching the Father to receive the blessing (grace, salvation) originally destined for the "firstborn" of Israel. This resonates profoundly with Paul's theology of grafting in Romans 9–11 and with the Church's self-understanding as the "new Israel" receiving covenant promises.
The agricultural imagery of dew, grain, and wine carries Eucharistic resonance that the Fathers and medieval theologians exploited fully. St. Thomas Aquinas, following patristic precedent, notes that grain and wine blessed by a patriarch point forward to the Eucharist in which Christ himself is the blessing given to the Church (Summa Theologiae III, q.74). The blessing is not merely material but sacramental in its trajectory.
Finally, the irrevocability of the blessing once pronounced mirrors the Catholic understanding of the indelible character of Baptism and Holy Orders (CCC §1272, §1582–1583): certain divine gifts, once given, cannot be taken back — "the gifts and calling of God are irrevocable" (Rom 11:29).
For Today
This passage challenges contemporary Catholics on two fronts. First, it confronts our tendency toward a tidy, merit-based theology of grace: Jacob receives the supreme blessing not because he is more virtuous than Esau, but because of divine election working through — and despite — human weakness and even sin. Grace is not earned; it is given. This should provoke an examination of conscience for those who believe their standing before God rests primarily on their own moral performance. Second, the irrevocability of Isaac's blessing invites Catholics to take seriously the permanence of their own baptismal identity and calling. You have been named, kissed, and blessed by the Father in Baptism — not because you presented yourself perfectly, but because Christ's "garments" were placed upon you. In moments of spiritual unworthiness or failure, the Catholic can return to this scene: the Father, drawing you near, smells not your own inadequacy but the fragrance of his Son in whom you are clothed (Gal 3:27), and blesses you still.
Cross-References