Catholic Commentary
The Desolation of Women After Judgment
1Seven women shall take hold of one man in that day, saying, “We will eat our own bread, and wear our own clothing. Just let us be called by your name. Take away our reproach.”
Isaiah 4:1 describes a catastrophic demographic collapse in Jerusalem where seven women desperately appeal to one man, offering to forfeit all material support if he will merely give them his name and remove their social reproach. The verse illustrates how widowhood and unmarried status carried theological stigma in ancient Israel, representing divine disfavor rather than mere misfortune.
Seven women beg to bear a man's name and nothing else—because in a world stripped of everything, a name is what proves you belong to someone.
Typological and Spiritual Senses
The Church Fathers read Isaiah through a Christological lens, and this verse — precisely because of its extremity and its placement just before the "Branch of the LORD" passage (4:2) — invites typological reading. The condition of these women — stripped of protection, clinging to any name that will remove their shame — is an image of the soul before grace: it has nothing of its own to offer, no righteousness, no merit (cf. Isaiah 64:6), and it asks only for the Name. St. Ambrose, commenting on the kindred imagery of the barren woman in Isaiah 54, writes that the Church herself was once "desolate" and found her fruitfulness only through Christ. The plea "let us be called by your name" becomes, in the spiritual sense, the cry of every soul at Baptism, where we are named in the name of the Trinity and incorporated into Christ (CCC 2156–2159). The "reproach" removed is the reproach of original sin.
Catholic tradition reads this verse within the unified canonical arc of Isaiah, which moves from judgment (chapters 1–39) to consolation (chapters 40–66) — a movement the Church reads as Law giving way to Gospel. The reproach (ḥerpāh) that these women carry is interpreted by the Fathers as a figure of the shame of sin itself, from which no human institution — not even lawful marriage — can ultimately deliver.
St. Jerome, in his Commentary on Isaiah, notes the contrast between these seven women of chapter 4 and the "seven women" as a figure of the universal human community seeking shelter, linking it immediately to 4:2's "Branch of the LORD" (tsemach YHWH), his preferred Messianic title. Jerome argues the juxtaposition is deliberate: human desolation is the canvas on which divine redemption is painted.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that the name of God is holy, and that to be named with God's name is to participate in his life (CCC 203, 2156). Baptism is precisely the sacrament in which the Church calls each person by name in the divine name (CCC 1267), removing what the rite of baptism itself calls the "reproach" — original sin and its alienation from God.
Furthermore, the Marian dimension should not be overlooked. The contrast between the desperate, unnamed women of 4:1 and the "virgin" of 7:14 — both in Isaiah — has led Catholic exegetes such as Cardinal Bea and, more recently, scholars following Dei Verbum §12's canonical approach, to see in Isaiah's women a foil for the one woman who, by her fiat, bore the Name above all names (Philippians 2:9) into the world, and whose reproach — far from shame — was the reproach of the Cross borne in love.
This verse confronts the contemporary Catholic with the reality that shame and the longing for an identity larger than oneself are not modern inventions — they are structural features of the human condition after the Fall. The seven women's plea — "just let us be called by your name" — resonates with every person who has sought identity in a relationship, a career, a social group, or an ideology, only to find that no human name ultimately satisfies the longing.
For Catholics today, the practical application is sacramental and liturgical: at Baptism, you were called by name in the Name of the Trinity. At Confirmation, that name was sealed. At every Eucharist, the Church is gathered "in His name." The shame — whatever form it takes in your life, from past sin to social marginalization to the feeling of divine abandonment — is what Christ came specifically to remove. Isaiah 4:1 is thus a diagnostic passage: it names the wound (reproach, namelessness, desolation) so that Isaiah 4:2–6 and ultimately the Gospel can name the cure. Let this verse prompt an examination of where you are still seeking a merely human name to cover a shame that only Christ's name can heal.
Commentary
Literal Sense — The Social and Historical Setting
Isaiah 4:1 is the final stroke of a devastating portrait of judgment that runs through chapter 3. There, the LORD stripped Jerusalem of its military leaders (3:1–3), its civil order (3:4–7), and finally turned his indictment on the proud daughters of Zion adorned with their finery (3:16–24). The logical conclusion of that military catastrophe now arrives: a generation of men has been decimated by battle (see 3:25, "your men shall fall by the sword"). Ancient Israelite society was structured so that a woman's identity, security, and honor were bound to her husband and her children. Widowhood or perpetual maidenhood carried genuine social stigma — the "reproach" (Hebrew חֶרְפָּה, ḥerpāh) — a word that elsewhere describes the disgrace of barrenness (cf. Genesis 30:23; Luke 1:25).
The Number Seven
The number seven is not accidental. In Hebrew idiom, seven signals completeness or fullness — here, the fullness of demographic devastation. So great is the slaughter of men that an entire community of women is left without husbands. The image deliberately shocks: the competition is not modest. Seven women, normally rivals, unite in a single collective plea, stripping away all pride to make their request.
"We will eat our own bread and wear our own clothing"
Under the terms of Mosaic marriage law (Exodus 21:10–11), a husband was bound to provide food, clothing, and conjugal rights to his wife. By waiving these legal entitlements, these women are not merely humble — they are abdicating the protections the Torah gave them. This signals the totality of their desperation: they ask for nothing material, only the one thing that cannot be bought — a name.
"Just let us be called by your name"
To be called by a man's name in ancient Israel meant to belong to his household, to have standing in the community, to be no longer "unclaimed." The phrase echoes the deepest human longing for belonging and identity. It is not primarily about romantic love; it is about personhood and social existence. To have no name-giver was to be socially invisible.
"Take away our reproach"
Ḥerpāh carries the weight of public shame, social exclusion, and perceived divine disfavor. Childlessness in the ancient world was interpreted theologically — not merely as misfortune but as a mark of divine displeasure (cf. Rachel in Genesis 30:23). The women's plea is therefore not merely social but quasi-liturgical: they are asking to be restored to the community of the blessed.