Catholic Commentary
Job Afflicted: Sores, a Potsherd, and the Ash Heap
7So Satan went out from the presence of Yahweh, and struck Job with painful sores from the sole of his foot to his head.8He took for himself a potsherd to scrape himself with, and he sat among the ashes.
Job 2:7–8 describes Satan striking Job with severe sores covering his entire body and Job sitting among ashes while scraping himself with a broken pottery shard, symbolizing his complete physical affliction and social degradation outside the human community. The passage emphasizes Job's radical humiliation through illness and abandonment, positioning him in the ash heap—the lowest social space in the ancient world—despite his blamelessness.
Job sits in ashes, scraping his wounds with a broken potsherd—a righteous man stripped entirely naked, outside the walls of human dignity, which is precisely where Christ will one day scrape at humanity's deepest wound.
Job 2:7 — "Satan went out from the presence of the LORD and struck Job with loathsome sores from the sole of his foot to the crown of his head."
The verse opens with a deliberate echo of 1:12 and 2:6: Satan "went out from the presence of the LORD." This structural repetition is theologically loaded. Satan acts only after leaving the divine presence and only within the limits God has set. The narrative will not allow the reader to imagine Satan as an autonomous agent of chaos; he operates under divine permission, not divine defeat. The Hebrew word translated "loathsome sores" (šəḥîn) is the same word used of the sixth plague of Egypt (Exodus 9:9–10) and of the skin disease that could render a person ritually unclean and force expulsion from the community (Leviticus 13). It evokes both cosmic judgment and social death. That Job is struck "from the sole of his foot to the crown of his head" — a merism, a totality-formula — signals that nothing of him is spared. He is not partially afflicted; he is comprehensively undone in body. The suffering is real, physical, and humiliating. Ancient Near Eastern literature frequently depicts illness as divine punishment or demonic attack; the Book of Job subverts this by insisting, as the narrator has already told us, that Job is tam ("blameless," 1:1) — making his suffering inexplicable by any simple moral calculus.
Job 2:8 — "And he took a piece of broken pottery with which to scrape himself while he sat in the ashes."
The potsherd (ḥereś) is a shard of broken fired clay, the most common and worthless object in the ancient Near East. Archaeological sites are built on layers of it; it is the debris of ordinary life. Job uses it to relieve the incessant itch and weeping of his sores — a pitiful implement for an unbearable condition. That he must do this himself, without the ministration of family or physician, deepens the image of abandonment. The "ashes" (ʾefer) place him symbolically and spatially outside the realm of the living. Ash heaps in the ancient world were located outside city walls, where rubbish, animal dung, and the refuse of households were burned. To sit on the ash heap (ʾašpôt) was to occupy the lowest possible social position — a space also associated with mourning, penitence, and death (cf. Psalm 113:7; Lamentations 4:5). Job has effectively been expelled from human community. He has lost wealth, children, and health; now he loses his very place among the living. The image is one of radical kenosis — a self-emptying of every worldly dignity.
Typological and Spiritual Senses
The Church Fathers consistently read Job as a figura Christi — a type of the suffering Christ. St. John Chrysostom (Commentaire sur Job, Homily 7) saw in Job's ash heap the humiliation of the Incarnation itself: the Lord of creation dwelling in the refuse of the world. St. Gregory the Great, in his monumental Moralia in Job (3.5–7), interprets the sores as the sins of humanity taken upon the Head of the Body, and the potsherd as the clay of human nature — shaped by God, cracked by sin — with which Christ scraped away corruption. The totality of Job's affliction ("sole to crown") prefigures the totality of Christ's Passion, in which no part of the body is left untouched by suffering. Gregory also reads the ash heap as the place where the Church does penance — a space of humility and conversion from which God raises the poor (Psalm 113:7).
Catholic tradition has never read Job's suffering as meaningless, though it rigorously refuses easy explanations. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that suffering, when united to the Passion of Christ, becomes participatory and redemptive: "By his passion and death on the cross Christ has given a new meaning to suffering: it can henceforth configure us to him and unite us with his redemptive Passion" (CCC 1505). Job does not yet know this; he suffers before the Incarnation. Yet Catholic typology holds that the grace of Christ is not bound by time, and that Job's faithful endurance was sustained by a grace looking forward to the Cross.
St. Gregory the Great's Moralia in Job — the most influential patristic commentary on the book and a foundational text in the Western monastic tradition — identifies Job's ash heap with the condition of the Church in via: always in the midst of the refuse of this world, always scraping at its wounds, yet not without hope. Gregory draws a specific connection between Job's potsherd and the clay God used to form Adam (Genesis 2:7), suggesting that in scraping his sores, Job performs an unwitting liturgy: humanity, made of clay, using clay to confront the wound of original sin.
Pope John Paul II's apostolic letter Salvifici Doloris (1984) — the Magisterium's most sustained meditation on suffering — cites Job as paradigmatic of the human cry before inexplicable pain. It teaches that in suffering, humanity is called not merely to endure but to ask — as Job does — and that this cry is itself a form of prayer. The Church does not demand silence in the face of affliction; it demands honesty before God, which is precisely what Job models. The ash heap, read through Catholic tradition, is not a dead end; it is the starting point of the most honest theology in Scripture.
Contemporary Catholics facing serious illness, chronic pain, or social humiliation — job loss, public failure, the stigma of mental illness — may find in these two verses not consolation of the sentimental kind, but the deeper solidarity of recognition. Job on the ash heap is the cancer patient in the hospital ward, the person whose grief has made them unwelcome at social gatherings, the elderly man whose body has become a source of shame. The Catholic response to such suffering is not to spiritualize it away but to name it clearly, as these verses do, and then to bring it into contact with the Passion of Christ.
Concretely: the Rite of Anointing of the Sick (James 5:14–15) is the sacrament the Church gives precisely to those who have been brought to their own ash heap. Catholics who are suffering physically are not merely encouraged but called by the Church to receive this sacrament — not as a last resort, but as an active participation in the redemptive suffering of Christ. Job's potsherd can become, for the Catholic, the chrism of anointing: a humble material thing through which the living God touches the wound.
Commentary