Catholic Commentary
The Call of Simon Peter and Andrew
18Walking by the sea of Galilee, he saw two brothers: Simon, who is called Peter, and Andrew, his brother, casting a net into the sea; for they were fishermen.19He said to them, “Come after me, and I will make you fishers for men.”20They immediately left their nets and followed him.
Matthew 4:18–20 describes Jesus calling Simon Peter and Andrew to become his disciples while they fish by the Sea of Galilee, commanding them to become "fishers of men." The men immediately abandon their nets and follow Jesus, demonstrating radical obedience to his sovereign call and beginning the formation of the church's foundational community.
Christ doesn't invite disciples to a school—he seizes their lives and makes them fishers of the Kingdom, asking them to leave everything now.
Matthew 4:18 — "Walking by the sea of Galilee" Matthew's staging is deliberate. Jesus is not in the Temple, not in a synagogue, not among the religious establishment of Jerusalem. He walks along a working shoreline, in the midst of ordinary Galilean labor. The Greek peripatōn ("walking") recalls the image of God walking in the garden (Gen 3:8) and the Wisdom figure who "walks" among her people (Sir 24:7). Matthew has just announced in v. 17 that Jesus began to proclaim, "Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand"; the calling of disciples is immediately the first act of that kingdom's arrival on earth. The Sea of Galilee (also called Tiberias or Gennesaret) was a freshwater lake of roughly 13 by 8 miles, the livelihood of the region and, as Matthew's audience would recognize, Gentile-proximate territory — "Galilee of the Gentiles" (v. 15, citing Isaiah 8–9). A mission that will eventually reach all nations begins, fittingly, at the edge of that frontier.
Simon is identified here as "the one who was called Peter" — a Matthean parenthesis that looks forward to the great confession and renaming in 16:17–18. He and Andrew are casting a amphiblestron, a circular throwing net used in shallow water. This is not the dramatic moment of recognition Luke narrates (cf. Lk 5:1–11, where a miraculous catch precedes the call); Matthew gives us the sparest, most direct version: Jesus sees, Jesus speaks, men follow.
Matthew 4:19 — "Come after me, and I will make you fishers of men" The phrase "Come after me" (Deute opísō mou) is the vocabulary of rabbinic discipleship, but with a decisive reversal of convention. In the Jewish world, students chose their rabbi; here the Rabbi chooses the students. This sovereign initiative is never incidental in the Gospels — it is constitutive. Jesus does not invite them to a school; he summons them into a relationship of sequela, of following a person.
The metaphor "fishers of men" (halieis anthrōpōn) is rooted in Old Testament imagery, though with a transformation. In Jeremiah 16:16, God sends fishers to catch Israel in judgment; in Ezekiel 47:9–10, the eschatological river teems with fish and fishermen stand along its banks in abundance. Jesus seizes the image and redeems it: the eschatological gathering is not judgment but salvation, not capture for condemnation but a drawing of humanity into the net of the Kingdom. The grammar is also significant: "I will make you" (poiēsō hymas) — the transformation is Christ's act, not the disciples' achievement. Peter and Andrew bring nothing but their willingness; the capacity for apostolic mission is entirely a gift of the one who calls.
Matthew 4:20 — "They immediately left their nets and followed him" The adverb eutheōs ("immediately") is Matthew's marker of radical, undelayed obedience — the same word used when Jesus is baptized and "immediately" goes into the desert (3:16; 4:1). There is no negotiation, no calculation, no request for time. The nets — their livelihood, their security, their family inheritance — are left behind (aphentes). This is not an impulsive act of naïve enthusiasm; it is an act that mirrors the logic of the Kingdom parables Jesus will later teach: the man who finds treasure in the field "goes and sells all he has" (Mt 13:44). The joy of what is found renders bearable, even joyful, the cost of what is left.
Typological and Spiritual Senses The four fishermen called in vv. 18–22 constitute the first cell of the Church. Patristic readers saw in the net the Church herself: cast wide, gathering all kinds. Origen (Commentary on Matthew 12.1) noted that the fisherman does not select his catch but draws in the whole sea; the sorting belongs to the eschatological judgment (cf. Mt 13:47–50). The immediate abandonment of nets figures the soul's detachment from created goods — not their condemnation, but their proper ordering beneath the call of God.
Catholic tradition reads this passage as the foundational act of apostolic succession and ecclesial structure. The call of Peter is not merely biographical; it is ecclesiological. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that "the Lord Jesus, after calling the Twelve and constituting them as a 'college' headed by Peter… made them sharers in his mission" (CCC 765). Matthew's placement of Peter first — and his anticipatory parenthesis "who is called Peter" — already signals what Ch. 16 will make explicit: that Simon's new identity as Petros is the foundation stone upon which the Church is built. The call on the lakeshore is, in miniature, the institution of the papacy in embryo.
The Church Fathers consistently interpreted the "fishers of men" metaphor in terms of the Church's universal missionary mandate. St. John Chrysostom (Homilies on Matthew 14.3) marveled that Jesus promised to make them fishers — acknowledging the disciples' unworthiness and insisting that the power to save souls belongs entirely to Christ, communicated through those he sends. St. Augustine saw in the net of the Church the mixed reality of saints and sinners drawn together until the final judgment (City of God 18.49).
Pope Francis, in Evangelii Gaudium (§120), echoes this passage directly when he calls every baptized Christian to understand themselves as missionary disciples — not merely recipients of grace, but active participants in the Church's fishing expedition. Vatican II's Ad Gentes (§5) grounds the Church's missionary nature precisely in this inaugural act: Christ himself initiates, constitutes, and empowers the mission. The vocation of the baptized is not merely to be caught in the net of salvation, but — in conformity with Peter and Andrew — to become fishers themselves.
The immediacy of Peter and Andrew's response is unsettling to the modern Catholic precisely because it is so unqualified. Contemporary discipleship tends toward negotiation: following Christ after the mortgage is managed, after the children are grown, after the career is established. These verses challenge that deferral at the root. The "nets" left behind need not be dramatic — they may be a comfortable indifference to parish life, an unchallenged habit of isolating faith from work, a reluctance to name Christ in ordinary conversation.
Practically, this passage invites an examination of conscience around vocational clarity: Do I know what Christ is specifically calling me to do, and am I doing it? Peter and Andrew did not receive a job description; they received a relationship and a direction — Come after me. For a Catholic today, this might mean accepting a role in RCIA, having a long-deferred conversation about faith with an estranged family member, or finally discerning whether a call to consecrated life or ministry has been suppressed for fear of cost. The nets are real. So is the one asking us to leave them.
Commentary