Catholic Commentary
Lament over Dwelling Among the Hostile
5Woe is me, that I live in Meshech, that I dwell among the tents of Kedar!6My soul has had her dwelling too long with him who hates peace.
Psalms 120:5–6 expresses acute spiritual anguish through the psalmist's lament of dwelling among hostile, uncivilized peoples far from Israel's covenant home. Meshech and Kedar—symbolic of distant, foreign lands—represent a soul in exile that knows it does not belong in this world, crying out against the spiritual alienation of prolonged separation from God.
The soul's discomfort in a hostile world is not a spiritual problem—it is a sign that you belong to God and are not yet home.
Catholic tradition brings a distinctive multi-layered reading to these verses by holding simultaneously their literal, allegorical, moral, and anagogical senses — what the Catechism calls the fourfold sense of Scripture (CCC §115–118). Literally, they express the distress of an Israelite living among pagan peoples hostile to the covenant. Allegorically, they prefigure the Church's condition in a world that does not recognize her Lord. Morally, they describe every baptized soul's experience of spiritual exile when immersed in environments hostile to virtue and truth. Anagogically, they express the final eschatological longing for heaven, the true Jerusalem.
St. Thomas Aquinas, commenting on the Psalms, noted that the soul's discomfort in a hostile world is not a defect but a sign of its supernatural orientation — the desiderium naturale for God that grace elevates and intensifies. This longing is not neurosis but theological sanity. Vatican II's Gaudium et Spes (§13) echoes this when it acknowledges that the human person experiences division within and hostility without as consequences of sin, yet notes that Christ has reoriented human longing toward its proper end.
St. Thérèse of Lisieux, in her Story of a Soul, captures the spirit of verse 6 when she describes the soul in exile: "The world is thy ship, not thy home." Her "little way" is precisely a response to this condition — not despairing of the hostile world, but passing through it with confident love, ascending toward God as the pilgrims ascended to Jerusalem. The Catechism's teaching that "the Church... will receive its perfection only in the glory of heaven" (CCC §769) confirms that dwelling "too long" in Meshech is the permanent penultimate condition of the Church Militant.
Contemporary Catholics often find themselves in precisely the situation these verses name — living, working, and raising families in cultural environments that are indifferent or actively hostile to the faith. Verse 5's image of Meshech can describe the aggressive secularism of a university campus, a corporate workplace where Christian ethics are treated as primitive, or a family table where faith is mocked. Verse 6's "too long" names the spiritual exhaustion that builds up from sustained immersion in such environments.
The practical application is twofold. First, the psalmist does not pretend the situation is comfortable — he laments honestly. Catholics are invited to bring this same honest anguish to prayer rather than suppressing or spiritually bypassing it. The lament is already a form of prayer, already an act of turning toward God. Second, the Song of Ascent context is crucial: the psalm does not end in Meshech. It begins there. The discomfort of exile is the spiritual fuel that launches the pilgrim toward Jerusalem. For Catholics today, that might mean intentionally nurturing friendship, liturgical life, and community with the Church — not as an escape from the world, but as the pilgrim's sustenance for the journey through it.
Commentary
Psalms 120:5 — "Woe is me, that I live in Meshech"
The exclamation "Woe is me" ('oy-lî in Hebrew) is a cry of acute distress, the vocabulary of lament found in the prophets (cf. Isaiah 6:5; Jeremiah 4:31). It signals not mere inconvenience but genuine anguish — the suffering of a soul out of place. Meshech is geographically striking: it refers to a people descended from Japheth (Genesis 10:2), associated in ancient Near Eastern literature with a fierce, semi-nomadic culture located in the region of Asia Minor or the Caucasus (cf. Ezekiel 38:2–3; 39:1). The name appears again alongside Kedar in verse 5, and the pairing is deliberately jarring — Meshech is in the far north, Kedar in the Arabian south — suggesting that the psalmist is not making a precise geographical claim but rather invoking two paradigmatic symbols of a world that is uncivilized, far-flung, and utterly foreign to Israel's covenant culture. To dwell in Meshech is to be stranded among people with no knowledge of, or reverence for, the God of Israel. The Hebrew verb gûr ("to live" or "to sojourn") is the same root used for the status of a ger, a resident alien — someone without full belonging. The psalmist identifies himself not as a citizen of this hostile world but as a stranger within it, which carries enormous theological freight in Israel's self-understanding.
Psalms 120:6 — "My soul has had her dwelling too long"
The verse continues and deepens the lament. "My soul" (nafshî) is the whole inner self, the animating center of the person. The phrase "too long" (rabbat, meaning "much" or "greatly") suggests not just duration but excess — a surfeit of exile that has become spiritually intolerable. The parallel with Kedar (the full verse reads "with those who hate peace") completes the geographic and moral picture. Kedar, descendants of Ishmael (Genesis 25:13), were known as skilled archers and herders who lived outside Israelite territory and covenant life; they appear in prophetic literature as a symbol of the pagan world (Isaiah 21:16–17; 42:11; Jeremiah 2:10). The soul is pictured as someone who has been forced to rent a room in a hostile land, longing for the true home from which it has been separated. The lament is not passive resignation but active spiritual protest — the soul knows it does not belong here, and that knowledge is itself a grace.
Typological and Spiritual Senses
The Fathers of the Church consistently read this psalm in light of the soul's condition in a fallen world. St. Augustine, in his , identifies Meshech with the earthly city — the built on self-love — in direct contrast to Jerusalem, the . The pilgrimage dynamic of the Songs of Ascent thus becomes, for Augustine, a map of the soul's entire journey through history. Meshech and Kedar are not mere place names but the permanent spiritual address of the self before conversion, and the address many believers still inhabit in part even after baptism. The of verse 6 is the groaning of the redeemed soul that has not yet arrived at full union with God — the eschatological tension Paul describes in Romans 8:22–23. Christologically, these verses can be read as the voice of the incarnate Son himself, who "came to his own home, and his own people received him not" (John 1:11), dwelling among the hostile as the supreme alien in a fallen creation.