Catholic Commentary
Complaint of Abandonment and Reproach
9I will ask God, my rock, “Why have you forgotten me? Why do I go mourning because of the oppression of the enemy?”10As with a sword in my bones, my adversaries reproach me, while they continually ask me, “Where is your God?”
Psalms 42:9–10 expresses the psalmist's anguished complaint to God, calling Him "my rock" while protesting that He has withdrawn His presence, and describing how enemies mock and wound him deeply by questioning his faith through taunts like "Where is your God?" The passage captures the spiritual paradox of maintaining trust in God even while experiencing profound abandonment.
In abandonment, the psalmist does not ask the void—he asks God, even calling him "my rock," holding faith and desolation in the same breath.
Catholic tradition brings several layers of illumination to these verses that other readings risk missing.
First, the legitimacy of the lament. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (§2589–2590) names the Psalms as the supreme school of prayer and explicitly acknowledges that they include "complaints" — prayers of petition that rise out of distress and even apparent abandonment. The Church does not sanitize this genre; she canonizes it. To cry "Why have you forgotten me?" is not irreverence but, in Augustine's formulation, a signum fidei — a sign of faith, because one only asks the question of a God one still believes is there.
Second, the Christological reading established by the Fathers is not a pious overlay but an interpretive key the New Testament itself supplies. The Gospels cite Psalm 22:1 from the Cross, teaching the Church to read the entire complex of lament psalms as, in their fullest sense, the prayer of Christ in his Passion. The Catechism (§2605–2606) teaches that in Christ's cry of abandonment, "he takes upon himself the totality of evil and sin" so that the Father's silence becomes the space of universal redemption.
Third, St. John of the Cross in The Dark Night of the Soul draws directly on this kind of psalmody to articulate the purgative dimension of mystical suffering. The felt absence of God — the rock who seems to have forgotten — is for John not a sign of God's withdrawal but of God's deeper work: stripping the soul of dependency on felt consolation so it may rest in pure faith. This gives Psalm 42:9–10 a vital place in the Catholic mystical tradition, not as a problem to be solved but as a grace to be received.
Contemporary Catholics navigating depression, chronic illness, grief, or spiritual dryness will recognize verse 9 with visceral immediacy: the sense that God, though confessed as rock and refuge, has gone silent. The temptation in such seasons is either to perform a false joy (pretending the desolation isn't real) or to conclude that the silence proves God's absence.
These verses refuse both exits. They model a third way: naming the wound honestly, but naming it to God. Notice the psalmist does not say "God has forgotten me" to his enemies or to himself — he says it to God. This is the difference between despair and lament.
Practically: bring verse 9 into your prayer in seasons of desolation. Use it literally — "I will ask you, my rock, why have you seemed absent?" Then sit in the paradox. The reproach of others (v. 10) may be internal voices that mock your faith precisely at its most vulnerable point: "Where is your God now?" Identify those voices. They are not God's. And notice that the psalmist's response to them is not self-defense but a return to God in prayer.
Commentary
Psalms 42:9 — "I will ask God, my rock: Why have you forgotten me?"
The verse opens with a deliberate act of will: the psalmist will ask — not "I am asking" in passive despair, but a conscious, forward-leaning resolve to bring his anguish before God. This signals that complaint directed to God is itself an act of faith, not its abandonment. The address "my rock" (Hebrew: sali, צוּרִי) is theologically charged. In the Hebrew scriptures, the image of God as rock (tsur) is one of the most stable divine epithets (cf. Deut 32:4, 18; Ps 18:2), connoting immovability, refuge, and the solidity on which a life can be built. The psalmist does not forget this even in his crisis — he addresses his complaint not to the void but to the very One he confesses as his foundation. This juxtaposition — "my rock" followed immediately by "why have you forgotten me?" — captures the spiritual paradox at the heart of the psalm: one cries out of abandonment to the One believed to be ever-present. The word "forgotten" (Hebrew: šəkaḥtanî) does not imply that God has ceased to exist, but that God's sustaining presence seems withdrawn, hidden. In the language of mystical theology, this is the experience of desolation — a felt absence that tests and ultimately deepens faith.
Psalms 42:10 — "As with a sword in my bones, my adversaries reproach me"
The image is brutally physical: the reproach of enemies is not merely verbal but somatic, lodged in his bones — the deepest structure of the self. The Hebrew idiom here (כְּרֶצַח בְּעַצְמוֹתַי, "like a crushing/shattering in my bones") conveys that mockery has penetrated to the marrow of his identity. The "adversaries" who reproach him almost certainly echo the earlier taunt of Psalm 42:3 and 42:10b: "Where is your God?" — a phrase that will recur in verse 10 of the Hebrew text. The enemies' weapon is not physical violence but theological ridicule: they attack precisely the point of deepest vulnerability, his trust in an apparently absent God. This is a distinctive cruelty — they do not merely wound the body but assault the soul's anchor.
The Spiritual/Typological Sense
The Fathers of the Church, reading this psalm Christologically, heard in verse 9 the cry of the incarnate Son. The question "Why have you forgotten me?" finds its fullest, most shattering expression on the lips of Christ at Golgotha: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Matt 27:46 / Ps 22:1). St. Augustine, in his , insists that Christ prays these psalms — in us, as the Head of the Body — transforming every human lament into a word uttered within the mystery of redemption. The reproach piercing the bones (v. 10) resonates typologically with the sword that pierced the side of Christ (John 19:34) and with Simeon's prophecy that a sword would pierce Mary's soul (Luke 2:35), suggesting that the suffering of this verse touches the very center of the Paschal Mystery.