Song of Solomon 5:2–8

Song of Solomon 5:2 — "I was asleep, but my heart was awake." The opening phrase establishes the dreamlike register of the entire passage. The Hebrew uses a participial construction (yešēnâ … ēr libbî) suggesting a suspended, liminal state: the body rests while the inner self remains alert. This is not mere literary ambiguity. The Bride is not fully asleep — she hears, she perceives — yet she does not act. The image is essential to the passage's moral and spiritual drama: she is capable of responding but chooses the comfort of rest. The voice she hears is her Beloved's: "Open to me, my sister, my love, my dove, my perfect one." Four terms of endearment cascade upon her like a series of urgent knocks, each one intensifying the entreaty.

Song of Solomon 5:3 — "I have taken off my robe. Indeed, must I put it on?" The Bride's reply is the spiritual crisis in miniature. Her excuses are domestic and, frankly, petty — she has undressed for the night, she has washed her feet. The very smallness of these obstacles throws the failure into sharp relief. She is not refusing out of hostility or indifference in principle; she simply does not want to be inconvenienced right now. Origen, in his Commentary on the Song of Songs, identifies this moment as the soul's most dangerous temptation: not the dramatic rebellion against God, but the quiet, comfortable postponement of response to grace. The robe and the clean feet become symbols of spiritual inertia — the soul wrapped in the garments of self-comfort.

Song of Solomon 5:4 — "My beloved thrust his hand in through the latch opening." The Beloved's persistence is remarkable. He does not leave immediately after her hesitation. He reaches through the latch-hole — a small aperture through which a hand or cord could manipulate an interior bolt — in one final, intimate gesture of effort. The phrase "my heart was moved for him" (or, in some translations, "my inmost being yearned for him") uses the Hebrew mē'ay hāmû, literally "my bowels trembled," the seat of deep emotional and visceral response in Hebrew anthropology. The body finally catches up to what the heart already knew. The sight of his hand — perhaps a glimpse, perhaps imagined — catalyzes a response that words alone could not.

Song of Solomon 5:5 — "I rose up to open for my beloved." The Bride's rising is laden with liturgical resonance. The myrrh dripping from her fingers onto the handles of the bolt suggests she had herself anointed — a detail that places her in readiness for an encounter of intimacy. Yet the myrrh also evokes sacrifice, anointing for burial (cf. John 12:3), and the costly, fragrant offerings of worship. Her whole body becomes an act of offering as she finally moves toward the door.

Song of Solomon 5:6 — "I opened to my beloved; but my beloved had withdrawn himself, and was gone." This is the devastating hinge of the passage. She opens the door and finds absence. The Beloved has gone (ḥāmaq 'ābar — literally, he "turned away and passed on"). His departure is not punishment so much as consequence: the moment of grace has a kairos, a proper time, and she missed it. The Bride's response is total desolation — "my soul went out when he spoke." She searches but does not find; she calls but receives no answer. This pattern — seeking without finding — is the purgative spiritual experience that the mystics will recognize as the via negativa, the dark night.

Song of Solomon 5:7 — "The watchmen who go about the city found me." Contrast this encounter with the one in 3:3, where the watchmen are benign figures who help the Bride in her first nocturnal search. Here they strike her, wound her, and take her veil. The violence is shocking. The watchmen, as guardians of the city's order, may represent religious authorities who fail to recognize authentic spiritual longing, or they may symbolize the chastening trials that accompany the soul's desolate search for God. Either way, the Bride is stripped and wounded — a figure now utterly vulnerable.

Song of Solomon 5:8 — "I adjure you, daughters of Jerusalem..." The Bride's charge to the daughters is incomplete in structure but urgent in tone: she does not ask them to find the Beloved in order to bring him back, but simply to tell him that I am sick with love. Her longing has become her only message. She is defined now entirely by the ache of his absence. This is not despair but a refined, purified desire — the soul that has moved through comfort, hesitation, loss, and suffering to arrive at a love stripped of all self-interest.

Catholic tradition reads the Song of Songs on multiple simultaneous levels, and this passage is among the richest in the entire book for theological depth.

The Patristic Reading: Origen of Alexandria, whose Commentary on the Song of Songs established the hermeneutical template for all subsequent Catholic interpretation, reads this passage as the soul (anima) that has received grace, grown accustomed to spiritual consolation, and then, through tepidity, fails to respond when Christ knocks. The robe and the feet are the soul's attachment to creature comforts. St. Bernard of Clairvaux, in his Sermones super Cantica Canticorum (particularly Sermons 51–57), treats this episode as a warning to monks — and all the baptized — against the spiritual vice of acedia (sloth), the failure to respond to divine invitation. Bernard identifies the moment the Beloved withdraws not as divine abandonment but as a pedagogy of desire: God withdraws the consolation of his felt presence so that the soul will seek him more ardently and with greater purity of motive.

The Marian Reading: The Church Fathers and medieval tradition, particularly St. Ambrose, read the Bride also as the Virgin Mary and as the Church. The veil taken by the watchmen resonates with the vulnerability of the Church under persecution (cf. Lumen Gentium, §8, on the Church as simultaneously holy and in need of purification). Mary, by contrast, is the Bride who never delayed — her fiat (Luke 1:38) is the anti-type of the Bride's hesitation in verse 3.

The Eucharistic and Sacramental Reading: The Catechism of the Catholic Church (§1386) warns against receiving the Eucharist unworthily or carelessly, recalling Paul's admonition. The Bride's failure to rise when the Beloved knocks has been read as a figure of the soul that approaches the sacraments without the requisite interior preparation — present in body, but the "robe" of charity not yet put on (cf. Matt 22:11–12).

The Mystical Reading: St. John of the Cross, in The Dark Night of the Soul, sees verses 6–8 as scriptural confirmation that God withdraws felt consolation precisely to purify the soul of its dependence on spiritual pleasure rather than on God himself. This is not absence but a deeper form of presence — the Beloved who withdraws so the soul will seek him beyond feeling.

For the contemporary Catholic, this passage offers a disquieting mirror. The Bride's excuse — "I have taken off my robe; must I put it on?" — is the voice of every person who has felt the interior prompting to pray but chose the comfort of a screen; who has sensed the call to go to Confession but found the timing inconvenient; who has felt moved to serve and found a reason to stay comfortable. The spiritual danger the passage names is not dramatic rebellion but the soft refusal of the inconvenienced will.

The passage also speaks to the experience of spiritual desolation — those seasons in which prayer feels empty and God seems absent. Catholic tradition, from Bernard to John of the Cross to Mother Teresa (whose private letters revealed decades of experienced spiritual darkness), insists that this felt absence is itself a form of purification and invitation. The proper response is not to abandon the search but to do what the Bride does: to keep seeking, to tell others of the longing, to let love become your only credential before God. A practical discipline: in moments of spiritual dryness, to persist in the liturgical hours, the rosary, or lectio divina not because they feel rewarding but because, like the Bride rising with myrrh on her hands, the act of reaching for the door is itself an act of love.