1 Corinthians 16:21–24

1 Corinthians 16:21 — The Autograph In antiquity, it was common practice for an author dictating a letter through a secretary (an amanuensis) to add a closing greeting in his own hand as a mark of authentication (cf. Gal 6:11; 2 Thess 3:17; Col 4:18). Paul explicitly calls attention to this gesture: "This greeting is by me, Paul, with my own hand." The emphasis is not vanity but verification. The Corinthian community had been plagued by factionalism and rival teachers (1 Cor 1:12), and false letters may already have circulated in Paul's name (cf. 2 Thess 2:2). The physical act of writing in his own script was thus a pastoral and apostolic seal — a guarantee that what they had heard read aloud was genuinely from the Apostle to the Gentiles. The verse also signals that everything preceding it carries the full weight of his authority.

1 Corinthians 16:22 — Anathema and Maranatha This verse contains two of the most electrifying phrases in the entire Pauline corpus, and they must be read together. The first, anathema (Greek for "accursed" or "devoted to destruction"), is a term with deep roots in the Old Testament ḥērem — the setting apart of something for divine destruction (cf. Deut 7:26; Josh 6:17). Paul has already used this word in Galatians 1:8–9, where he pronounces it on anyone who preaches a false gospel. Here, however, the criterion is not doctrinal error per se but love: "If anyone does not love the Lord Jesus Christ, let him be accursed." This is striking. The whole of Christian ethics and doctrine, as Paul sees it, is predicated on a personal, relational love for the person of Jesus — not merely intellectual assent to propositions about Him. To withhold this love is to be outside the covenant community entirely. The anathema is therefore not an act of cruelty but of clarity: it names the absolute, non-negotiable center of Christian existence.

Immediately following — with no softening transition — Paul cries out Maranatha. This is one of the oldest surviving Christian prayers, preserved here untranslated from the Aramaic, suggesting it was so ancient and so established in liturgical use that Paul (writing in Greek) simply reproduces it intact, confident his readers will recognize it. The Aramaic can be parsed two ways: Maran atha ("Our Lord has come" — a confession of the Incarnation) or Marana tha ("Our Lord, come!" — an eschatological petition). Early patristic tradition, supported by the Didache (10:6), and most modern scholars favor the latter reading: it is a prayer, not a statement. The juxtaposition of anathema and Maranatha is therefore profoundly theological. The anathema defines who stands outside the assembly; the Maranatha is what the assembly does — it orients itself toward the returning Lord. To love Christ is, concretely, to long for His coming. The anathema and the prayer are two sides of the same coin.

1 Corinthians 16:23 — The Grace Blessing "The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ be with you" is the standard Pauline benediction (cf. Rom 16:20; 2 Cor 13:13; Gal 6:18; Phil 4:23), but placed here, after the anathema and the Maranatha, it takes on a particular weight. Grace (charis) is the freely given, unmerited favor of God — the very opposite of the condition described in the anathema. To those who do love the Lord, grace is promised. The blessing is not a formality; it is an invocation that calls down divine favor on the community as the letter is concluded and, in all likelihood, as they prepare for or are already gathered at the Eucharist.

1 Corinthians 16:24 — Personal Affection The letter closes on a note of remarkable tenderness: "My love to all of you in Christ Jesus." After chapters of correction, controversy, and solemn warning, Paul does not end with severity. He ends with love — specifically, love "in Christ Jesus," reminding the Corinthians that the unity binding Paul to them is not merely human affection but participation in the Body of Christ. The "Amen" ratifies the whole as a liturgical act. This final note mirrors the entire letter's pastoral logic: truth without love is cold and destructive; love without truth is sentimentality. Paul demonstrates both.

Typological and Spiritual Senses Typologically, the gesture of Paul's own hand echoes the divine "writing" of the Law on stone tablets (Exod 31:18) — now replaced by the Apostle's personal inscription on the hearts of the community (cf. 2 Cor 3:3). The anathema echoes the prophetic "Day of the LORD" traditions, while the Maranatha anticipates the Bride's cry in Revelation 22:20 ("Come, Lord Jesus!"), binding the beginning and end of the canonical New Testament together in one continuous prayer of eschatological longing.

From a Catholic perspective, these four verses are a window into the Church's earliest liturgical and doctrinal self-understanding, and Catholic tradition illuminates them at several distinct levels.

The Anathema and Conciliar Authority The word anathema employed here by Paul became the Church's own formal term for defining the outer boundaries of defined doctrine. From Nicaea (325) to Trent (1545–1563) to Vatican I (1870), Ecumenical Councils pronounced anathemas precisely in imitation of Pauline usage — not as expressions of hatred, but as solemn, authoritative declarations of what lies outside the communion of faith. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (§2089) warns against apostasy and heresy as ruptures of the covenant of faith. Paul's criterion — the love of Christ — grounds this tradition not in legalism but in relationship.

Maranatha and the Eucharist The Didache (c. 80–120 AD), the earliest non-canonical liturgical document of the Church, uses Maranatha as a liturgical acclamation within the Eucharistic prayer (Did. 10:6). This strongly suggests that 1 Cor 16:22 was read aloud within a Eucharistic assembly — and that Paul's letter was itself embedded in early liturgical worship. St. John Chrysostom (Homilies on 1 Corinthians, 44) identifies the Maranatha as the supreme prayer of Christian longing. The CCC (§1130) teaches that "the Church celebrates the mystery of Christ until He comes" and that "Maranatha" is the very heartbeat of Eucharistic worship. Every Mass, in this sense, is a communal Maranatha.

Grace as the Seal of Love St. Thomas Aquinas (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 110) teaches that grace (gratia) is the participation in the divine nature — not merely God's goodwill toward us, but His life within us. Paul's grace-blessing is therefore an invocation of this transforming divine indwelling. The benediction is not ornamental; it is a priestly act. That love and grace close the letter together reflects the Catholic understanding that charity (caritas) is itself a supernatural gift — not merely human affection elevated, but God's own love poured into our hearts (Rom 5:5).

Personal Love for Christ The anathema's criterion — not loving the Lord Jesus — underscores what the CCC (§428) calls the "personal encounter with Christ" at the heart of Christian life. The whole moral and doctrinal edifice of the faith rests, for Catholic tradition, on this primary, personal relationship of love. As Benedict XVI wrote in (§1): "Being Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event, a person, which gives life a new horizon."

For contemporary Catholics, these verses issue a quietly radical challenge. The anathema is not directed at heretics in some abstract sense — it is aimed at lovelessness toward Christ, which is a temptation that can exist inside the most devout pew. Paul implies that one can perform all the external gestures of Christian life and still fail at the single, decisive criterion: a living, personal, ardent love for the Lord Jesus. This is a summons to examine not our doctrinal correctness, but the temperature of our hearts.

The Maranatha has immediate practical power: it is a prayer Catholics can adopt personally and liturgically. In a culture that trains us to live entirely within the present — productivity, news cycles, immediate gratification — "Come, Lord!" is a counter-cultural, counter-anxious act of faith. It reminds us that history has a direction and a destination.

Finally, Paul's closing declaration of personal love — after an entire letter of hard correction — models what good pastoral leadership, good marriage, and good friendship look like: truth spoken within a frame of genuine love, never divorced from it. Catholics in positions of authority (parents, catechists, clergy, teachers) can meditate on the ordering of Paul's final lines: anathema, then Maranatha, then grace, then love. Severity without tenderness is not apostolic.