Catholic Commentary
The Ruin of His Offspring and the Decay of His Body
10His children will seek the favor of the poor. His hands will give back his wealth.11His bones are full of his youth, but youth will lie down with him in the dust.
Job 20:10–11 describes the fate of a wicked man's descendants and his own mortality. His children will be forced to seek the favor and appeasement of the poor whom he exploited, while his youthful vigor and strength accompany him only to the grave, representing the futility of a life devoted to wickedness.
Injustice does not die with the sinner—it passes to his children, and his wasted strength returns to dust unfruitful.
Catholic tradition reads the Book of Job not only as moral instruction but as a profound participation in the mystery of suffering, justice, and divine providence. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that "God is in no way, directly or indirectly, the cause of moral evil" (CCC 311), and that innocent suffering, far from disproving divine justice, participates mysteriously in the salvific order. Zophar's speech in Job 20 represents what the Catechism implicitly warns against: a flattened, mechanical application of retributive justice that denies the complexity of God's providential design (cf. CCC 309–314).
Saint Gregory the Great, in his monumental Moralia in Job, reads the wicked man of Zophar's speech as a figure of the spiritually proud — those who amass worldly virtue and reputation without true interior conversion. Gregory notes that the "bones full of youth" signify carnal self-confidence: the soul that trusts in its own strength rather than in grace "descends into the dust of its own pride." This anticipates Thomas Aquinas's teaching that pride (superbia) is the root of all sin — a youth of power that refuses to mature into humility.
The fate of the wicked man's children connects to Catholic social teaching's consistent concern for intergenerational justice. Laudato Si' (§159–162) warns that unjust actions by one generation impose burdens upon future generations — an echo of this ancient biblical insight. The children who must "seek the favor of the poor" are an image of structural consequences that outlast individual sin. True repentance and restitution, the Church teaches, are necessary precisely because sin has social and temporal reach beyond the sinner himself (cf. CCC 1459).
These two verses offer a searching examination of conscience for contemporary Catholics in several concrete ways. First, they challenge the comfortable assumption that material success is a sign of God's favor — a temptation alive and well in prosperity-gospel thinking and in subtler forms of cultural Catholicism. Zophar is wrong about Job, but the principle he invokes is real: wealth built on injustice does not endure, and its collapse touches those we love most.
Second, verse 11's image of bones "full of youth" going to dust is a powerful memento mori for a culture obsessed with physical vitality and youth. The Catholic tradition of meditating on death (meditatio mortis) is not morbid escapism but a clarifying discipline. If our energy, talent, and youthful strength are not directed toward God and neighbor now, they will return to dust unused. The Sacrament of Reconciliation is the Church's concrete provision for turning the vigor of one's life back toward its proper end before it is too late. Ask: What am I doing with the strength I have, while I have it?
Commentary
Job 20:10 — "His children will seek the favor of the poor."
The Hebrew verb rendered "seek the favor" (יְרַצּוּ, from rāṣâ) carries the nuance of appeasing or placating, and in some manuscripts suggests the children must make restitution to the poor for what the father took unjustly. The word "poor" (דַּלִּים, dallîm) refers specifically to those of low social standing — the very people whom the wicked man likely exploited in his rise to prosperity (cf. Job 20:19: "he has oppressed and forsaken the poor"). The irony is sharp and deliberate: the wicked man's heirs inherit not wealth but obligation and humiliation. The reversal of fortune here is a classic biblical motif of divine justice: the oppressor's dynasty does not simply end; it is made to bow before the very ones it crushed.
Zophar intends this as a statement of cosmic moral order — a world governed by a God who vindicates the poor. Yet the reader already knows, from the Prologue (Job 1–2), that Job is not guilty of such sins. Zophar's theological framework is not wrong in principle; it is catastrophically misapplied. His error is one of false certainty: he reads the principle of retributive justice as a diagnostic tool to identify Job's hidden sin, rather than as a general truth about the moral structure of creation.
Job 20:11 — "His bones are full of his youth, but it shall lie down with him in the dust."
This verse requires reading the full couplet: "His bones are full of his youth / but it [his youthful vigor] shall lie down with him in the dust" (the second half is frequently omitted in lectionary clusters but is exegetically essential). The image is of a man whose physical vitality — the marrow of youth, the strength stored in the bones — accompanies him not to glory but to the grave. The "bones" in Hebrew anthropology are not merely anatomical; they represent the core of personal identity and vitality (cf. Psalm 51:8; Ezekiel 37). To say that his bones are "full of youth" is to say that wickedness cuts a man down before his vigor is exhausted — he dies full of unlived life, unrealized potential, wasted strength.
The image may also carry a moral register: the youthful energy that should have been consecrated to righteousness was instead poured into sin, and now returns to dust, unfruitful. There is a tragic quality here that, while Zophar means it as condemnation, functions within the broader Book of Job as a meditation on mortality itself — not only the mortality of the wicked, but of all flesh.
The Spiritual Sense
Typologically, these verses anticipate the New Testament's theology of inheritance and bodily resurrection. The "children seeking favor from the poor" evokes the reversal announced in the Beatitudes (Matthew 5:3). The image of youth decaying in the dust points toward the Pauline contrast between the "perishable" body sown in the earth and the "imperishable" body raised in glory (1 Corinthians 15:42–44). In the spiritual sense, the "bones full of youth" that go down to dust speak to every human being's experience of squandered gifts — and the urgent need for conversion before the grave.